Hussey, I don’t fully get the point you are trying to make.
You yourself have backed out of several deals because of bad audits. So the system is also working for you. The account you mention first off, you actually refused the audit, after I mixed it up as and Instagram account and @swapd fixed it up and even asked you a second time for an audit which you refused and said everything was fine. Then you have gone to resell the page and found it had an issue. What more can we do in that situation?? You could have audited that account twice and didn’t, we can only offer your the protections, not make you take them.
On your points on language that also doesn’t make much sense. How are supposed to give you universal facts about these accounts during a 15-20 minute audit process. Faking just about any metric is incredibly easy and we do our utmost best to gain from the account owners the true history of the account. Then we use our combined market knowledge and past history of transactions to build a profile of each account and its likely position. But how can we ever speak in absolutes?? Owners often lie, and make false claims, register fakes as organic, hide cross promotion, we can never be certain about the history of an account 2 years ago, but we can look these accounts over and look for trends and flags that would cause concerns or reasons to believe there is an issue.
Both of those statements are perfectly reasonable and sum up the activity on your pages. You seem to be upset that you purchased pages without using the audit system or from elsewhere and then they failed audit when you went to sell them.
Truthfully I’m kind of stunned to see you arguing against a system that you were happy on multiple occasions saved you from purchasing weak accounts. The auditing system can and never will be perfect or absolute, but I guarantee that as an admin team we go above and beyond and argue for and against failing accounts.
In both the above instances you mention, after looking them over I 100% agree with the admin and the other information they showed in our admin group.